Showing posts with label hunger games. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hunger games. Show all posts

Saturday, May 26, 2012

On an Unnecessary Number of Shades of Grey

Erika Leonard, I begrudge you nothing but the millions of dollars you'll make
exploiting the market's overall lack of taste in fiction.
You're no worse than the Disney Channel.

I'll admit, I'm completely a hypocritical elitist when it comes to books. I know what good literature is and I know what good writing is, in the non-fictitious realm, and I know that just because something is popular doesn't make it automatically bad writing.

I mean usually, but not always. ("Hunger Games" proved its worth to me.) Likewise, just because genre nerds love something doesn't make it good either, nor is a book well written just because I like it. Frankly, the bulk of my shelves are still Star Wars novels. They're not even particularly solid, anymore, just genre tropes, but I'm 40 years into a continually expanding universe. I'm plot committed. (Glad somebody else uses that term, apparently.)

Still, "Fifty Shades of Grey" is a piece of garbage I wouldn't tough if it were recycled into the only toilet paper in a five block radius.

Yes, yes, I bitched out "Harry Potter" and "Twilight" before it, but those at the very least had the distinction of gearing towards children and teens. This book began as "Twilight" erotic fan fiction and is selling like a new iPhone. It is not good, it is not even fun. It has all the undercurrent popularity of mild pornography smuggled into tree houses from brothers' backpacks.

And honestly, I'm fine with it.

Worst-case scenario, nothing happens aside from another terrible movie adaptation trilogy, currently rumored to star Alex Skarsgard. That could at least be a lot of sexy times in 4 hours of television men will get dragged to. Way more than Bridget Jones' Diary.

Best case? A whole generation of women latch onto light-to-moderate BDSM play as a weekend fetish on par with the Sexy Pirate swashbuckler novels and $8 naughty nurse VHS tapes.


Still, I'm thinking about exercising that "We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone for any reason" clause if any more 14 year-olds ask for it.

We put age ratings on the manga and even shrink wrap the more violent ones or anything that draws the nipple. We shrink wrap "The Big Butts Book" in Photography for the same reason: while technically listed as it, the artistic merits of the nudity are questionable, especially in light of commercial and obscenity laws.

"Fifty Shades" is listed as 'Erotica' right on the back cover, and I'm selling it to grandmothers, mothers, and girls who were dropped off here on their way to the movies which, if rated R, would require their chaperone. Some local girls are even trying to read it for their high school's Free Choice quarterly book project.

Alright, I might steal that eight page sex contract/questionnaire, though. That might be useful at some point.

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Why I Revoke My Approval of Harry Potter

"I am the night! I AM THE BATMAN!"
I was too old for Harry Potter.

Though others my age started in and said "It's really not that young; you'd like it," I preferred reading material intended for adults. Frankly, I blame grade school and New York State's teachers possessing an inability to assign reading not depicting children horribly abused or otherwise stranded in the wild, and brought to the brink of suicide. You know, good, old-fashioned murderporn.1

Everything's perspective, though. Rowling had the good sense to age her characters along with her readers. As the kids grew old enough to handle mature themes, they became more immediate within the text. Hell, there was swearing. Cursing too, but that muggles the waters a bit.2

And of course Twilight became a thing that happened.

Alright, I was willing to give HP its props for getting a whole generation across the globe reading and feeling the good vibes.

But now owls are dying because of it.

I saw a dead owl on the side of the road the other day. Those of you who follow me on twitter might have heard already, but it was weird. Just a crow picking at an owl carcass. And the only trees were ludicrously high. Either that owl landed for the express purpose of laying down to die splayed out, failed to dive-bomb a field mouse and pull up in time, or it just keeled over and fell 150 feet from its final resting perch.

And it just might have been your fault, for loving Hedwig so much.

Or, I mean, it could have been like a wicked fat brown hawk or something.




1 I fully expect The Hunger Games and Battle Royale to be required school reading within the next decade. At least I could justify the first. Battle might have to be an independent study.

2 ZING!

Saturday, March 24, 2012

The Hunger Games: Should I See It?

1. Did you love the book?

a) No - Go for it.
b) Yes - Watch it once, but try to pretend the book was like normal teen fiction, devoid of symbolic objects, backstory, or psychological mind games.


*Light SPOILERS follow*

I'll try to be as non-specific as possible, but you've been warned.

Plus:
It was going to be incredibly difficult to adapt a movie from source material written in the first person present tense, with an unreliable narrator. In asking for movies with decent first-person narration, I was pointed to Fight Club and Good Fellas, both past-tense. Present tense narration is just inner monologue and it doesn't really work, like characters in children's programming stating their thoughts out loud because there isn't another character present. In fact, that's exactly what it is.

Hunger Games pulled it off, though. Just a few glances here and there, and a lot of the "we're thinking things we're not saying" moments worked out. As Gizmodo already reported, most of the movie flows from Katnis' perspective, even when she's unconscious or hallucinating. However a few key shots, Haymitch wooing sponsors, Caesar Flickerman and a co-announcer supplying in-universe commentary on the Games, and clips of spectators or Game Makers reacting to events manage to make up for a sizable fraction of the information which Katnis, in the book, expressed as common knowledge.

Minus:
Still, a lot of important details got left by the wayside. Many of the psychological elements of the Capitol's traps are lost. The significance of the mockingjay, both as a pin and as the animal symbol of district resistance, also gone. Katnis' unspoken communication with Haymitch is entirely missing.

Final Verdict:
Go see it, go enjoy it as a cool, teenage, post-apocalyptic Battle Royale, just with mostly white kids. Don't go expecting a perfectly faithful adaptation of the book. That might have worked if this had been a miniseries or a three-season show on Sci-Fi or another C-list cable channel.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Unoriginality In Hollywood | The same story you've read 8 times before

Saw the midnight premier of The Hunger Games last night. Full review will go up tomorrow. As much as I'd like to be on top of all the juicy, gory details, go see it for yourselves first. I consider this the 24 hour Spoiler Grace Period. I'll put up a warning for a week, but after that it's you're own damned fault.

In the mean time, here's a complete list of the movies currently showing in my local theater:

 Based on a famous, out-of-copyright novel series, with several previous movie incarnations.

 Based on a best-selling novel by an author who has had multiple previous works filmed.

 Completely unoriginal concept, a tired trope in vaguely new packaging. Quality of said packaging remains to be seen, though reviews seem to be fairly disappointing  overall.

 Again, a popular book series turned into a movie. The book itself being a–granted, very well executed and richly backstoried–rehashing of the Battle Royale "kids forced to fight to the death" trope, itself a variation on the Thunderdome scenario, or generic gladiatorial combat.

 "Eddie Murphy has a physical quirk which sets him apart from other people, but being forced to deal with this makes him learn about himself and grow as a person." That's a trope in and of itself.

 Actually an original concept. Sad that it's effectively "reality" T.V., meaning mostly staged to resemble true events, but it's still an original idea that was intended start-to-finish as such.

 Remake of a T.V. drama. Now a craptacular twenty-something stoner comedy.

 Sequel to a remake of a movie of a myth.

Bastardization of a beloved children's book.


To twist the knife a bit, previews of upcoming movies shown prior to Hunger Games included:

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo DVD - Remake of a Swedish movie of a book.

G.I. Joe 2 - Sequel to a remake of a cartoon/toy commercial with multiple spin-off franchises

Prometheus - Amazing looking new sci-fi film by Ridley Scott, unfortunately still a loose prequel to Alien.

Snow White and the Huntsman - Retelling of a classic fable concurrent with another that looks infinitely worse.

Teaser for Twilight: Breaking Dawn, Pt. 2 - End of an adapted novel series.

Hollywood doesn't have writers so much anymore, as they have editors.