The tragedy of George Zimmerman is that he probably really did feel
threatened by a seventeen year old black man wearing a hoodie, walking
through his neighborhood.
At its most banal retelling,
George Zimmerman was a passably inept member of his neighborhood watch,
who thought it was suspicious that a dark-skinned teenager would be in
the area, walking calmly through the rain. He stalked this man, was
confronted by this man, and this resulted in George's gun going off at
close range, killing Trayvon Martin.
Media and the
public at large are furious that Zimmerman was acquitted of murder
charges, but trying Zimmerman for murder now in a federal court with
hate-crime statutes attached is not really going to make anyone but
Trayvon's family feel better. It does not guarantee that actual racists
will think twice before casually murdering anyone and then relying on
"good ol' boy" regional politics to claim self-defense.
George
Zimmerman is actually proof that our society is evolving to hold its
members to an ethical standard higher than the bare minimum of the law.
By all accounts, George handled his situation … badly.
Let's just say that. He unnecessarily engaged in pursuit of a
"suspect," entered what he believed to be a dangerous situation against
police advice, and then failed to identify himself while accusing the
victim in a generic and contextually racist [in hindsight] manner.
George Zimmerman was something of an idiot. I think that's a fair judgement to apply.
But
George Zimmerman did not commit a hate-crime, he did not seek to murder
a young black man, at least as far as anyone involved in the case can
really discern. He was, for all the condescension the phrase lends, playing cops and robbers like a fucking child.
I mean to be profane, I am sorry, for the case calls for such. It is profane that a grown man who claims to suffer from Adult ADHD and require medication to remember things such as the street he lives on can acquire a firearm, or that he be allowed to join even an amateur, volunteer organization dedicated to safety. It is profane
that he has come to perceive through media and social stigma a black
man in a hooded sweatshirt as "suspicious" for his neighborhood.
I will now stoop to prove a point:
George
Zimmerman is half Peruvian, that half being one-quarter
African-Peruvian. His father is German Catholic. He is a registered
Democrat. A twenty-eight year old Afro-Hispanic Democrat thought that a
sweatshirt makes a black man suspicious enough to warrant investigation
for recent burglaries. This is a simplification, but the disgusting fact
is not by much.
George Zimmerman might have watched a lot of Law & Order, or The Wire, or Saved By the Bell for all we know. For whatever reason, this man thought another man was behaving suspiciously at the very best because he was out looking to find people behaving suspiciously, at the worst because Trayvon's being black was suspicious enough.
The
sad truth is George probably really did feel threatened by a seventeen
year old black man wearing a hoodie, walking through his neighborhood.
He put himself in a stupid situation, handled it poorly, reducing the
number of possible outcomes to the one wear he ended up on trial for
murder, because what seems to have happened was staggeringly less likely
than the idea that he was simply a violent racist.
George Zimmerman did
behave like a racist when he profiled Trayvon Martin as "up to no
good." He internalized every image of gangbangers or hoodlums or early
'90s gangster rappers and he broadened that imagery to include a young
black man when he assigned himself the role of a police officer.
That
we as a public want George tried in a federal court after a jury found
his actions to fall short of either second-degree murder (intentional)
or manslaughter (even involuntary), shows that we are "uncomfortable"
with this outcome, to say the least. Many wish him tried because they
feel his racial profile led to the encounter which escalated into
(in)voluntary manslaughter. Others will demand a retrial on grounds that
the prosecution handled its case badly, or that local law enforcement
was less than equal in the pursuit of justice.
Yet
I'm pretty sure a great deal of this unrest lies in the nagging feeling
that we have perpetuated even now a culture of casual racism and its
acceptance that could allow an event such as the ending of Trayvon
Martin's life.
The idea that "urban" means "Angry Black Man in Flashy Clothes."
The idea that "gangbanger" has any real meaning outside the most destitute, war-torn ghettos of American metropolises.
The
idea that–let's just say it–black people are criminals. Violent
criminals. That white men are gentlemen thieves stacking banking
regulations against themselves, but anyone of relatively-recent African
descent is automatically predisposed to acts of base ignorance, cruelty,
inconsideration, and physical damage.
Trayvon Martin's
death was not a murder, though that would leave us all more settled,
having a wrong, racist, vile murdered to condemn as out-of-step with the
rest of us. If his death was not a crime, by the letter of the law,
then that means we have, as a progressive and just society, have allowed
social perceptions to skew so terribly and so covertly that a hate
crime can be committed in our eyes by accident.
The
tragedy of Trayvon Martin was his horrible death. The tragedy of George
Zimmerman is that he really was doing what he thought was right, and it
was all legal.
Dave Zucker
www.soundadoggymakes.com
Dave@soundadoggymakes.com
Showing posts with label trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trial. Show all posts
Thursday, July 18, 2013
The Travesty and Tragedy of George Zimmerman
Labels:
acquittal
,
Florida
,
george zimmerman
,
gun control
,
murder
,
race
,
racism
,
stand your ground
,
travon martin
,
trial
Monday, December 3, 2012
IMPEACH THE O-EMPEROR | I do not think that word means what you think it means
As I was driving to the train station today through the area locally known as Mahopac Falls and Carmel, but more widely referred to as "East Bumblefuck," I passed a sign scrawled haphazardly in what appeared to be bootblack, across a large piece of plywood and nailed to a tree at the edge of the property on which was set back an adorably rustic redneck cabin, overlooking the road.
The sign read, "Impeach the O-Emperor."
Actually, it said "Impeach O- the emperor," but based on the font size, I'm going to assume that graphic design and layout night classes at the local community college were not available to this particular budding Banksy before he–women have far more legible handwriting–dropped out to fulfill a rewarding career as a comparatively cheaper substitute for a forklift.
Now, I get the impression that your intent was the removal of President Obama from office. As such, I find myself compelled to explain that to "impeach" means to level charges against.
Likely, you learned this term during the Clinton trials, when you discovered it was possible to oust a sitting president from office before the expiration of his term for the simple reason that you disagreed with his party affiliation, and found this knowledge more sexually arousing than your browser history's strange and mysterious fixation on Thai ladybois.
Now, to actually remove the president, Obama would have had to do something illegal. And not your Bill O'Reilly talking-box classroom understanding of illegal, mind you, actually illegal. After being charged, he would then have to be tried, and then convicted of those charges. Even then, I am not entirely sure that a prisoner could not also remain President of the United States, though there are certainly measures by which the legislature could remove him once convicted.
Than said, no U.S. president has ever been run out of office through impeachment. Johnson and Clinton, the only two presidents ever impeached despite demands to do so dating all the way back to Washington, were both acquitted in Senate hearings. Worst case scenario, a doomed Commander in Chief could simply resign prior to charges being formally filed, as Nixon did, after appointing Gerald Ford to replace his disgraced Vice President, thus bargaining a pardon upon Ford's own ascension.
Secondly, an "Emperor" isn't an elected office you could impeach, you moron.
The sign read, "Impeach the O-Emperor."
Actually, it said "Impeach O- the emperor," but based on the font size, I'm going to assume that graphic design and layout night classes at the local community college were not available to this particular budding Banksy before he–women have far more legible handwriting–dropped out to fulfill a rewarding career as a comparatively cheaper substitute for a forklift.
Now, I get the impression that your intent was the removal of President Obama from office. As such, I find myself compelled to explain that to "impeach" means to level charges against.
Likely, you learned this term during the Clinton trials, when you discovered it was possible to oust a sitting president from office before the expiration of his term for the simple reason that you disagreed with his party affiliation, and found this knowledge more sexually arousing than your browser history's strange and mysterious fixation on Thai ladybois.
Now, to actually remove the president, Obama would have had to do something illegal. And not your Bill O'Reilly talking-box classroom understanding of illegal, mind you, actually illegal. After being charged, he would then have to be tried, and then convicted of those charges. Even then, I am not entirely sure that a prisoner could not also remain President of the United States, though there are certainly measures by which the legislature could remove him once convicted.
Than said, no U.S. president has ever been run out of office through impeachment. Johnson and Clinton, the only two presidents ever impeached despite demands to do so dating all the way back to Washington, were both acquitted in Senate hearings. Worst case scenario, a doomed Commander in Chief could simply resign prior to charges being formally filed, as Nixon did, after appointing Gerald Ford to replace his disgraced Vice President, thus bargaining a pardon upon Ford's own ascension.
Secondly, an "Emperor" isn't an elected office you could impeach, you moron.
Labels:
bill o'reilly
,
clinton
,
constitution
,
gerald ford
,
hearings
,
idiots
,
impeach
,
law
,
morons
,
nixon
,
Obama
,
pardon
,
politics
,
president
,
stupid people
,
trial
,
whitewater
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)